Skip the Comma: Situations That Don’t Call for One on the ACT

A comma can clarify a sentence—or make it incorrect. ACT English questions often offer choices that differ only in punctuation. The reliable approach is to identify what each phrase does before deciding whether to put a comma around it. In the enhanced ACT English section, you answer 50 questions in 35 minutes, so recognizing a sentence’s structure is more useful than memorizing an oversimplified “pause here” rule.

Do not separate essential identifying information

A restrictive or essential phrase tells the reader which person or thing you mean. In “The students who submitted their forms received confirmation,” the clause identifies the students. Commas would turn it into extra, nonessential information and change the intended meaning.

By contrast, “The students, who had already submitted their forms, received confirmation” treats the clause as additional information about all the identified students. Commas around nonessential clauses come in pairs when the clause interrupts a sentence. The ACT expects you to preserve the intended meaning, not merely add punctuation around every relative clause.

Essential appositives also resist commas: “The novelist Toni Morrison won the Nobel Prize.” Whether a name or description is essential depends on how the surrounding sentence identifies its subject. A nonessential version is “Toni Morrison, a novelist, won the Nobel Prize.”

Do not place a comma between subject and verb

Even when the subject is long, it normally connects directly to the verb: “The results of the latest experiment suggest a new explanation.” Writing “The results of the latest experiment, suggest …” incorrectly separates subject from predicate.

The same principle applies to a verb and its essential object: “Researchers measured the temperature” needs no comma after “measured.” Additional nonessential material may change the pattern—“The researchers, after checking the equipment, measured the temperature”—but the commas then surround the interruption rather than dividing the sentence core.

Do not automatically place a comma before a final dependent clause

When a short, closely connected dependent clause follows an independent clause, the comma is often unnecessary: “We stayed inside because the storm intensified.” The reason clause is integral to the statement. In contrast, a dependent clause that opens the sentence is often followed by a comma: “Because the storm intensified, we stayed inside.”

Meaning and readability can justify punctuation with a final clause, especially where contrast, interruption or ambiguity is involved. Do not use “never before because” as an absolute test rule. Read the whole sentence and consider whether removing the comma improves the intended relationship.

Do not confuse a compound predicate with two independent clauses

Compare “Maya checked the figures and sent the report” with “Maya checked the figures, and Leo sent the report.” The first has one subject performing two actions, so a comma before “and” is normally unnecessary. The second joins two independent clauses, so a comma before the coordinating conjunction is standard.

If two independent clauses are joined only by a comma, the result is usually a comma splice: “The timer rang, everyone stopped writing.” Repair it with a period, semicolon, or a comma plus a coordinating conjunction: “The timer rang, and everyone stopped writing.” Removing the comma without adding a proper connection would merely create a run-on sentence.

Do not break a natural phrase or comparison

A preposition and its object generally stay together: “The team worked with experienced tutors.” An infinitive also normally stays together: “They hoped to improve their timing.” Inserting a comma inside either phrase disrupts the grammatical relationship.

In a straightforward comparison, do not add punctuation solely because the comparison contains “than” or “as”: “This passage is longer than the first.” A comma may be appropriate when another grammatical structure requires one, so focus on that structure rather than the word alone.

Know where commas really are needed

Correct “no comma” decisions become easier when you can recognize necessary commas. Commas often separate coordinate items in a list, follow introductory material and surround nonessential interruptions. For example: “After reviewing the data, Lila revised the chart” and “The chart, which had been mislabeled, was revised.”

Direct address also uses punctuation: “Jordan, please check the answer.” That comma addresses Jordan; it does not separate the subject from the verb. A transition at the start of a sentence may call for a comma—“However, the results were inconclusive”—because its function differs from an essential clause.

Work through the ACT choice in three passes

First label the sentence parts: independent clause, dependent clause, essential description or aside. Second compare the punctuation options and ask which meaning they express. Third reread the entire sentence with your choice inserted. If punctuation creates a fragment, comma splice or awkward separation, eliminate it.

For practice, decide whether the bolded section needs commas: “The book that I borrowed yesterday is on the desk.” It identifies the particular book, so no commas are needed. But in “My copy of the book, which I borrowed yesterday, is on the desk,” the relative clause adds nonessential detail and is set off.

Related practice on lists, introductory phrases and nonessential clauses appears in the published ACT English comma rules guide. For section timing and tested skills, consult the current official ACT English outline. The goal is not fewer commas in every sentence; it is punctuation that matches grammar and meaning.

  • img